14 Comments
User's avatar
Alicia Dara's avatar

Catherine, I so appreciate the sentiments in this post as I'm helping the elderly people in my life navigate their final years. Many people (especially women!) go their whole lives feeling guilty about any kind of pleasure, and I've learned a lot from watching older people let go of all that. Inspiring!

Expand full comment
Catherine Hiller's avatar

A deep thank you for this, Alicia. I always hope my writing will give joy and somehow be useful.

Expand full comment
kathleen lawrence's avatar

this was very moving. Food for thought here. Some thing I'm going through. Thanks so much.

Expand full comment
Catherine Hiller's avatar

I am so happy to hear this, glad to help in any small way.

Expand full comment
Mark Thompson's avatar

One of the bigger surprises in my work with the elderly was the positive response of terminally ill patients going on hospice. No more heroic measures. They were now free to pursue whatever small pleasures they could enjoy while they were kept comfortable. In some cases, their physical and mental status actually improved!

Expand full comment
Catherine Hiller's avatar

This is fascinating, the idea that hospice confers a kind of peace. And hospice can last many months—just ask Jimmy Carter!

Expand full comment
Charlie Seton's avatar

I had an older friend who had lived with Diabetes from childhood. When he went into hospice, his caretakers said that he could have as much ice cream as he wanted - for the first time in his long life. He was THRILLED!

Expand full comment
Charlie Seton's avatar

Beautifully and sensitively written!

Expand full comment
Catherine Hiller's avatar

Thank you.

Expand full comment
Nigel Holloway's avatar

My mother's mental decline lasted nine years from the age of 80 when she fell in the street. I believe that those last nine years did have a purpose, even though she was not aware of it. Her purpose was essentially the same as it always had been since I was born, which was to be there for me and my sister. Jesus Christ said 'my service is perfect freedom' - and my mother embodied this. She found her purpose in being a mother, with all that this means, right up until her death. She and my father were my role models. This does not mean she was selfless. Being an only child in the midst of Hitler and his war meant something special in terms of being self-centered. She always needed fulsome compliments for her cooking for example. This fault, such as it is, seems so minor now, though it wasn't when I was a teenager. When all is said and done, my sister and I were at the center of her self.

Expand full comment
Melissa Knox's avatar

Yes, yes, yes! My mother is 102--and a half! Just overcame her second bout with COVID, loves ice cream, listening to Gilbert&Sullivan, being read Wordsworth and Shakespeare. There's no memory (kind of a plus for me) but I'm so glad she's enjoying herself.

Expand full comment
Catherine Hiller's avatar

Me, too. We are lucky. Some people with dementia are angry or sad. But not our mothers!

Expand full comment
Catherine Hiller's avatar

Thanks for this other perspective on "purpose." And on compliments on dinner! I get that, I'm with your mom. I want more than "very good," I want, "The sauce is especially rich. Did you use shallots or onions?"

Expand full comment
Megan McCarthy's avatar

Beautiful and true.

Expand full comment